Skip to main content

Breath, Eyes, Memory

December 3, 2009
Book of the Day: Breath, Eyes, Memory, by Edwidge Danticat
Grade: C+
First published: 1994
1-word review: Tested
8-word review: Women can be awfully mean to each other.

This book was written by a women named Edwidge. Why aren't more women named Edwidge?

Like the main character in this novel, Sophie Caco, Edwidge Danticat was born in Haiti and raised by an aunt and grandmother after her mother emigrated to the United States. Also like Sophie, she herself emigrated to the U.S. when she was twelve years old. Other than these facts, I don't know how much of this novel is autobiographical.

Here is a photo of Edwidge.


Here is a map of Haiti, a third-world country, sometimes called the "Idaho of the Caribbean."


And here's a photo of Reese Witherspoon, who has never lived in Haiti.


I won't spoil the story by going into too much detail, but Sophie comes to be damaged by her mother, who was herself damaged by her mother (and a young Haitian man). Sophie's aunt, Tante Atie, is also damaged by those close to her. So, everyone's a little screwed up, as is the country of Haiti, at the time suffering through decades of the Duvaliers' brutal dictatorship and the thuggery of the Tonton Macoutes, Haiti's infamous secret police.

Incidentally, I highly recommend a Graham Greene novel, The Comedians, which details the story of a British expat living in Haiti during Papa Doc's rule. His depictions of the Tonton Macoutes are truly frightening.

The book is frequently quite moving, but it feels a little unpolished, as if it could have used a good editor. It was its author's first novel, published when she was only 25, and it shows at times. I rarely say this about any book, but this one could have benefited from being a little longer. We just skip over most of Sophie's experience growing into adulthood in her mother's home.

All in all, I'd like to read more by Edwidge. Also, I like saying Edwidge.

Edwidge.

Comments

  1. JoeDecember 4, 2009 at 11:49 PM

    Hey man, I need you to read The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman. I have to read it by January...so if you just read it and write about it on your blog one of these days I think that should count!

    ReplyDelete
  2. LauriAnnDecember 5, 2009 at 12:19 AM

    I can handle your criticism of Boise and Idaho because my fine state produces well-rounded, open-minded people in addition to potatoes. I also know that it is a misguided ploy to get another invitation from me to visit the Gem State to "prove" to you that you are wrong. You had your chance. You better just appreciate the precious time you already got to spend there, and hope for the day you can return.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Erik DrydenDecember 5, 2009 at 7:32 PM

    Joe, I wouldn't want to deprive you of the joy of reading.

    And don't ban me from Idaho, whatever you do! I still haven't visited its museum to its African-American.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Freddy the Detective

December 11, 2009 Book of the Day: Freddy the Detective , by Walter R. Brooks Grade: A- First published: 1932 1-word review: Porcine 5-word review: Don't mess with the pig. Freddy the Pig awakes one morning to find Hambone, his best friend and longtime sty-mate, missing. He begins an investigation into the disappearance only to stumble upon the dismembered and eviscerated corpse of Hammy hanging in a meat locker. He proceeds to take revenge on those he deems responsible, doing to them what was done to his buddy. Blood flows as Freddy self-destructs in an orgy of violence. This is all rather surprising to find in a children's book. Warning to my more sensitive readers! Here's a gruesome picture of some of Hammy's remains, shown only in the interest of science. Here we have Idaho.
3 comments
Read more

A Month in Books (December 2009)

I'm sure you as my massive reading audience greatly enjoyed my month in books (not that I'm suggesting that you, dear reader, are personally massive). This will be my last post until my next Book-a-Day month, at a yet to be determined point in the future. Here are my December awards: Book of the Month Award - Arabian Nights and Days , by Naguib Mahfouz Honorable Mentions - Homage to Catalonia , by George Orwell; The Atom Station , by Halldor Laxness; The Spy Who Came in from the Cold , by John le Carré Worst Book Award - The Museum of Dr. Moses: Tales of Mystery and Suspense , by Joyce Carol Oates Dishonorable Mention - Into the Wild , by Jon Krakauer And here are some of the things I learned over the month of December: If you choose to read a book a day, pick a month other than December to do it, even though you'll be out of school. The holidays really screw with the reading time. Avoid trying to read a short story collection in a single day. Write in your blog immediat...
1 comment
Read more

Disgrace

December 12, 2009 Book of the Day: Disgrace , by J.M. Coetzee Grade: A First published: 1999 1-word review: Brutal 9-word review: South Africa's still struggling in the aftermath of apartheid. A communications professor in Cape Town resigns his job after having a scandalous affair with a student. He visits his daughter on her ranch in the country, where they are viciously attacked and robbed in her home. The rest of the novel, in sparse and nearly perfect prose, deals with the aftermath of this attack, examining white guilt, police incompetence, and intellectual bankruptcy. Coetzee is a white South African who wrote a novel that depicts black on white violent crime in his country. As you may expect, this has generated quite some controversy, despite Coetzee's bona fide anti-apartheid status. Many critics have suggested that Disgrace should be read as an allegorical tale about the inadequacies of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, a body set up in South Africa to exam...
3 comments
Read more